North Lima Pizza

Discover North Lima Pizza in North Lima, OH, your go-to spot for delicious cheese pizza, hearty steak subs, and flavorful options at great prices. Enjoy friendly service and a cozy atmosphere. Call +1 330-549-9859 today!

Welcome to North Lima Pizza

Taste the Difference.

North Lima Pizza
North Lima Pizza
North Lima Pizza
North Lima Pizza

Step into North Lima Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of North Lima, Ohio. This cozy pizza spot offers a variety of savory delights crafted to satisfy every craving. Located at 11681 South Ave, North Lima, this restaurant stands out for its warm atmosphere and friendly service. The aroma of fresh cheese and baked crust welcomes you as soon as you walk through the door. Whether you're after a classic cheese pizza or something with a little more flair, you’ll find options that don't break the bank, with an average price of $11.75. Expect both cash and check accepted here, making it easy for everyone to join in the fun.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

11681 South Ave, North Lima, OH 44452, United States

Phone

+1 330-549-9859

About

The Culinary Story

North Lima Pizza
North Lima Pizza
North Lima Pizza
North Lima Pizza

North Lima Pizza prides itself on being a community favorite, beloved for its delicious offerings and affordable prices. The menu features nine pizzas in total, including standout items like the classic cheese pizza, steak toppings, and of course, the highly praised Brier Hill style. Each pizza is prepared with fresh, quality ingredients, ensuring every bite is satisfying. North Lima Pizza doesn’t just stop at pizza; their subs provide an equally delectable option for those looking for something different.

Owner's commitment to customer service shines through, as many patrons feel like family upon entering the restaurant. Inside, the décor is simple and inviting, drawing in both regulars and new customers alike.

In this little oasis of flavor, locals gather to share meals, stories, and laughter, establishing connections over shared love for good food. The commitment to community extends beyond just serving meals, as North Lima Pizza often supports local events and initiatives.

Whether it's a sports team pizza night or just some good neighbors gathering, you'll find a sense of camaraderie here. Don’t forget to grab a pizza to go, perfect for any gathering or a cozy night in. North Lima Pizza encapsulates the spirit of North Lima—friendly, welcoming, and always delicious.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday12-5:30 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-5:30 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-5:30 PM
  • Friday11 AM-5:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-5:30 PM

North Lima Pizza impresses with its diverse menu, featuring pizzas of various sizes to cater to different appetites. Choose from 14-inch or 12-inch round pizzas, or go for the smaller 8-inch option if you're looking for a quick bite. The specialty Brier Hill pizza, available in both 14-inch and 12-inch versions, draws locals in with its unique take on a classic.

This restaurant also excels in providing a comfortable dining experience with friendly staff who remember regular customers—creating a welcoming community vibe. With options perfect for solo diners or families, North Lima Pizza ensures everyone feels at home.

North Lima Pizza

North Lima Pizza features a charming exterior that invites diners to come inside and enjoy a meal. Situated along South Avenue, it stands out with a simple yet appealing storefront that reflects its community-focused vibe. Outdoor seating allows you to enjoy the fresh Ohio air while savoring your pizza—a perfect spot during pleasant weather. The relaxed atmosphere fosters conversations among friends and families, embodying the essence of small-town dining.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Had to stop by & try a new pizza place in North Lima. The sauce is just lovely with a hint of sweetness to it. They are also generous with the sauce & cheese. All three were tasty & there is a nice crunch on the crust. Had a chat with the owner & learnt a little history behind this business that has been in North Lima for over 30 years. I loved hearing that he makes his own pizza dough & it was obvious he loves & takes pride in it. It always makes it more endearing to visit a place that you meet the owner who is quick to greet & chat but that the community loves this place too. It's certainly a desired place of destination & rightly so.

K
Kim's M.

We have eaten at 10 different pizza places in the area. This is hands down the best one. Chicago style in my opinion as its thick with tons of cheese. We will and continue to order here all the time. No wings though. So well priced too...

R
Ronald S.

First time getting take out. Very friendly and great food! Possibly the best meatball hoagie I've ever had. The white pizza was great too!

J
John U.

Came here for the first time for pizza, I got extra cheese, pizza was very good, cheese was perfect, this was one of the best pizza I've ever had. Staff was great too. Will definitely be back.

J
Jim W.

Really enjoyed our pizza. We live in florida and really look forward to the pizza in the youngstown area when we come home for a visit. We had seen reviews on Facebook and thought we give it a try. We were not disappointed. You aren't able to eat in strictly take out. This was a problem for us because pizza wasn't hot when we got back to where we are staying.

D
Dee H.

My parents ordered from here on a regular basis, especially when we had gatherings. It was amazing! Now when my husband and I have a reason to pass by we have to get a pizza. We were here a few days ago but we were SO excited to dig in I forgot to take a picture, lol! I'll try to remember next time. You should try it, you won't be disappointed! (we get a lovely medium cheese and pepperoni - pure deliciousness)

D
Denise R.